Manuscript Evaluation

Ideal for writers who want big-picture feedback and a clear revision strategy before investing in a full developmental edit. You'll receive a detailed editorial letter analyzing your manuscript's strengths, weaknesses, and revision priorities.

Submit an Inquiry

  • A comprehensive read-through of your manuscript focused on story-level elements such as structure, pacing, character development, plot cohesion, and reader engagement.

    Unlike a full developmental edit, this service does not include extensive in-manuscript comments. Instead, feedback is delivered through a detailed editorial letter designed to help you revise with confidence.

  • This service is ideal for authors who:

    • Have a completed manuscript draft

    • Are seeking professional feedback before querying

    • Are preparing for self-publication

    • Want revision guidance without a full markup

    • Are unsure whether they're ready for a developmental edit

    • Story structure and plot progression

    • Character arcs and development

    • Pacing and narrative momentum

    • Stakes and conflict

    • Theme and emotional resonance

    • Worldbuilding (when applicable)

    • Reader engagement and clarity

    • Market readiness and positioning

    • Comprehensive editorial letter (typically 4–6+ pages)

    • Analysis of manuscript strengths

    • Identification of key revision opportunities

    • Prioritized revision recommendations

    • Actionable next steps for your next draft

    • Professional developmental perspective on your story

  • Custom quoted based on manuscript length.

    Current rate: $0.024 per word

    Turnaround times vary based on manuscript length and current availability.

    Payment plans available for larger projects.

  • What's the difference between a Manuscript Evaluation and a Full Developmental Edit?

    A manuscript evaluation provides big-picture feedback through an editorial letter. A full developmental edit includes both the editorial letter and detailed comments throughout the manuscript itself.

    Will my manuscript be edited directly?

    No. This service focuses on the editorial letter rather than extensive in-text commentary.

    Do I need a completed manuscript?

    Yes. A complete draft is strongly recommended so feedback can address the story as a whole.

    How detailed is the editorial letter?

    Most editorial letters are 4–6+ pages and include strengths, weaknesses, revision priorities, and actionable recommendations.

    Which service should I choose if I'm on a budget?

    A manuscript evaluation is often the best starting point for writers who want professional developmental feedback without investing in a full developmental edit.